10 models to compare

Does equal dog flying disc diameter mean equal weight?

Hero Air 235 and SuperHero 235 both have a 235 mm diameter; Hero’s nominal weights are 108 g and 141 g respectively.

Size and weight cannot establish chewing safety. Follow maker play and supervision instructions.

Disclosure: SnoutPicks participates in the Amazon Associates Program and may earn commissions from qualifying purchases through product links on this site.

With no preferences selected: Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue) is one option to compare.

No hands-on testingMethod and sources

Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue) · first with a product link

Nominal weight: 95.3 g.
Construction: Nylon and rubber.

What to note:

Not listed by the maker: diameter.

View at Chuckit!

If you choose Up to 165.1 mm for diameter, the first option with a product link becomes Hero Pup 120.

10 models compared; 10 have a product-page link.

The picks

5 options to compare

Compare the details that matter to your setup.

An option to compare

Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue)

Nominal weight: 95.3 g.

Key details

Construction: Nylon and rubber.

What to note

Not listed by the maker: diameter.

Compare specs: Nominal weight: 95.3 g here; 88 g on SuperAtom 185 Firm.

Nominal weight: 95.3 gConstruction: Nylon and rubber

See all 3 specs

Nominal weight95.3 g

ConstructionNylon and rubber

DiameterNot listed by the maker

2 of 3 specs available · source checked September 28, 2026 · Source ↗
Chuckit! · Product page checked September 28, 2026

View at Chuckit! Compare

Diameter: Up to 165.1 mm

Hero Pup 120

Nominal weight: 23 g.

Key details

Diameter: 120 mm.

What to note

Not listed by the maker: construction.

Compare specs: Nominal weight: 23 g here; 95.3 g on Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue).

Diameter: 120 mmNominal weight: 23 g

See all 3 specs

Diameter120 mm

Nominal weight23 g

ConstructionNot listed by the maker

2 of 3 specs available · source checked September 28, 2026 · Source ↗
Hero Disc USA · Product page checked September 28, 2026

View at Hero Disc USA Compare

Diameter: Up to 235 mm

Air 235

Nominal weight: 108 g.

Key details

Construction: Plastic.

What to note

Diameter: 235 mm.

Compare specs: Nominal weight: 108 g here; 95.3 g on Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue).

Diameter: 235 mmNominal weight: 108 gConstruction: Plastic

See all 3 specs

Diameter235 mm

Nominal weight108 g

ConstructionPlastic

3 of 3 specs available · source checked September 28, 2026 · Source ↗
Hero Disc USA · Product page checked September 28, 2026

View at Hero Disc USA Compare

Construction: Natural rubber

Flyer (Small, KF15)

Nominal weight: 122.5 g.

Model / item: Flyer KF15

Key details

Construction: Natural rubber.

What to note

Diameter: 177.8 mm.

Compare specs: Nominal weight: 122.5 g here; 95.3 g on Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue).

Diameter: 177.8 mmNominal weight: 122.5 gConstruction: Natural rubber

See all 3 specs

Diameter177.8 mm

Nominal weight122.5 g

ConstructionNatural rubber

3 of 3 specs available · source checked September 28, 2026 · Source ↗
KONG · Product page checked September 28, 2026

View at KONG Compare

Also compare 5

SuperAtom 185 Firm

Diameter: 185 mm.

Key details

Nominal weight: 88 g.

What to note

Construction: Plastic.

Compare specs: Diameter: 185 mm here; 235 mm on SuperHero 235.

Diameter: 185 mmNominal weight: 88 gConstruction: Plastic

See all 3 specs

Diameter185 mm

Nominal weight88 g

ConstructionPlastic

3 of 3 specs available · source checked September 28, 2026 · Source ↗
Hero Disc USA · Product page checked September 28, 2026

View at Hero Disc USA Compare

Comparing Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue) · SuperAtom 185 Firm

Compare

Save this comparison

Already have a model in mind?

Compare

The facts that differ

Choose up to three models to compare side by side.

Differences only

0 identical specs shown. Details that do not apply to these models are omitted.

Published specification comparison
Spec	Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue)No preferences selected.	SuperAtom 185 FirmNo preferences selected.
Diameter	Not listed by the maker	185 mm
Nominal weight	95.3 g	88 g
Construction	Nylon and rubber	Plastic

Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue)

No preferences selected.

Diameter: Not listed by the maker
Nominal weight: 95.3 g
Construction: Nylon and rubber

SuperAtom 185 Firm

No preferences selected.

Diameter: 185 mm
Nominal weight: 88 g
Construction: Plastic

Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue)

View at Chuckit!

SuperAtom 185 Firm

View at Hero Disc USA

Compare all 10 models

— = no verified listing yet. The published order is independent of links.

All models and their decision specs
Product	How it compares	Key spec	Compare	Action
Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue)	Compared with SuperAtom 185 Firm: nominal weight, 95.3 g vs 88 g.	Nominal weight: 95.3 g	Compare	View at Chuckit!
Air 235	Compared with Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue): nominal weight, 108 g vs 95.3 g.	Diameter: 235 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
Hero Pup 120	Compared with Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue): nominal weight, 23 g vs 95.3 g.	Diameter: 120 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
SuperAtom 185 Firm	Compared with SuperHero 235: diameter, 185 mm vs 235 mm.	Diameter: 185 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
SuperHero 235	Compared with SuperStar 235: nominal weight, 141 g vs 135 g.	Diameter: 235 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
SuperStar 235	Compared with Xtra 235 Distance: nominal weight, 135 g vs 110 g.	Diameter: 235 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
Xtra 235 Distance	Compared with Xtra 235 Freestyle: nominal weight, 110 g vs 105 g.	Diameter: 235 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
Xtra 235 Freestyle	Compared with Zisc Flying Disc (Small, 6.5-inch): diameter, 235 mm vs 165.1 mm.	Diameter: 235 mm	Compare	View at Hero Disc USA
Flyer (Small, KF15)	Compared with Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue): nominal weight, 122.5 g vs 95.3 g. Model / item: Flyer KF15	Diameter: 177.8 mm	Compare	View at KONG
Zisc Flying Disc (Small, 6.5-inch)	Construction: Zogoflex; Diameter: 165.1 mm.	Diameter: 165.1 mm	Compare	View at West Paw

Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue)

Compared with SuperAtom 185 Firm: nominal weight, 95.3 g vs 88 g.

Nominal weight: 95.3 g

CompareView at Chuckit!

Air 235

Compared with Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue): nominal weight, 108 g vs 95.3 g.

Diameter: 235 mm

CompareView at Hero Disc USA

Hero Pup 120

Compared with Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue): nominal weight, 23 g vs 95.3 g.

Diameter: 120 mm

CompareView at Hero Disc USA

SuperAtom 185 Firm

Compared with SuperHero 235: diameter, 185 mm vs 235 mm.

Diameter: 185 mm

CompareView at Hero Disc USA

SuperHero 235

Compared with SuperStar 235: nominal weight, 141 g vs 135 g.

Diameter: 235 mm

CompareView at Hero Disc USA

SuperStar 235

Compared with Xtra 235 Distance: nominal weight, 135 g vs 110 g.

Diameter: 235 mm

CompareView at Hero Disc USA

Xtra 235 Distance

Compared with Xtra 235 Freestyle: nominal weight, 110 g vs 105 g.

Diameter: 235 mm

CompareView at Hero Disc USA

10 catalog models

How the comparison works

Your choices are compared with each model’s product details. A missing or conflicting value stays unknown and cannot satisfy a choice you select. The starting order helps you browse; it does not rate real-world performance.

Source dates appear with each link below. A source date does not confirm today's price or stock.

Finder methodology Report a correction

Sources for all 10 models

Air 235: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
Flyer (Small, KF15): Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
Hero Pup 120: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
Paraflight Flyer (Small, Orange/Blue): Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
SuperAtom 185 Firm: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
SuperHero 235: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
SuperStar 235: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
Xtra 235 Distance: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
Xtra 235 Freestyle: Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026
Zisc Flying Disc (Small, 6.5-inch): Source 1 ↗ · September 28, 2026

Same diameter, different nominal weights

Hero Disc USA Air 235 and SuperHero 235 both measure 235 mm in diameter, but their nominal weights are 108 g and 141 g respectively. Diameter does not determine nominal weight. Known diameters span 120 to 235 mm; known nominal weights span 23 to 141 g.

Hero Disc USA's nominal weights are approximate and subject to manufacturing tolerances. With dimensions and nominal weights as our sources rather than throwing trials, we cannot judge flight behavior or how long a disc will last.

Compare the exact disc size before its material

Plastic, natural rubber, nylon and rubber, and Zogoflex are construction descriptions in this comparison. They do not measure flight or resistance to chewing. Some construction values are unknown, so a missing material should stay an open question rather than become an assumed plastic disc.

The discs from the other makers represent their Small variants. Select that size on the product page and follow the maker's use instructions. Unknown weights or diameters are left empty instead of being borrowed from a larger size or inferred from unlabeled outside dimensions.

Before you buy

What does nominal weight mean?

Hero lists an approximate weight with a manufacturing tolerance. The number shown is the nominal value, not a measurement of the particular disc you will receive. Hero Air 235 and SuperHero 235 both have a 235 mm diameter; Hero’s nominal weights are 108 g and 141 g respectively. The nominal weight differs. Air suits a lower-weight preference at the same diameter, but manufacturing tolerance applies. Neither diameter nor weight establishes chewing suitability or safety; follow the maker’s play and supervision instructions.

Why are some measurements missing?

A missing weight or material remains unknown. Chuckit lists overall dimensions without identifying the diameter, so those dimensions are not used as a diameter.

Do the disc dimensions describe every available size?

West Paw Zisc, KONG Flyer and Chuckit Paraflight use the Small version here. Select that named size for your comparison; another size needs its own measurements and play instructions for your dog.