SnoutPicks logoSnoutPicks
All finders A–Z

10 models to compare

Clay or wheat cat litter, and how deep a fill?

Material sets maker and fill depth here. Six Dr. Elsey's clays call for 3-4 in; four sWheat Scoop wheats call for 4 in.

Seven skip added scent; Fresh Linen alone adds fragrance among eight with scent labels.

Disclosure: SnoutPicks participates in the Amazon Associates Program and may earn commissions from qualifying purchases through product links on this site.

With no preferences selected: Cat Attract® Litter is one option to compare.

No hands-on testingMethod and sources

Cat Attract® Litter · first with a product link

  • Base material: Clay.
  • Recommended fill depth, minimum: 3 in.
What to note:

Not listed by the maker: published fragrance label.

View at Dr. Elsey's

If you choose Wheat for base material, the first option with a product link becomes Fresh Linen Cat Litter.

10 models compared; 10 have a product-page link.

The picks

5 options to compare

Compare the details that matter to your setup.

An option to compare

Cat Attract® Litter

Base material: Clay.

Key details

  • Recommended fill depth, minimum: 3 in.

What to note

Not listed by the maker: published fragrance label.

Base material: ClayMaker describes as clumping: YesRecommended fill depth, minimum: 3 in
See all 5 specs
Base materialClay
Maker describes as clumpingYes
Recommended fill depth, minimum3 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum4 in
Published fragrance labelNot listed by the maker

4 of 5 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
Dr. Elsey's · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at Dr. Elsey's
Base material: Wheat

Fresh Linen Cat Litter

Base material: Wheat.

Key details

  • Recommended fill depth, minimum: 4 in.

What to note

Maker describes as clumping: Yes.

Base material: WheatMaker describes as clumping: YesPublished fragrance label: Added natural fragrance
See all 5 specs
Base materialWheat
Maker describes as clumpingYes
Published fragrance labelAdded natural fragrance
Recommended fill depth, minimum4 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum4 in

5 of 5 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
sWheat Scoop · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at sWheat Scoop
Published fragrance label: No added perfume

Ultra+ Litter

Published fragrance label: No added perfume.

Key details

  • Base material: Clay.

What to note

Maker describes as clumping: Yes.

Base material: ClayMaker describes as clumping: YesPublished fragrance label: No added perfume
See all 5 specs
Base materialClay
Maker describes as clumpingYes
Published fragrance labelNo added perfume
Recommended fill depth, minimum3 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum4 in

5 of 5 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
Dr. Elsey's · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at Dr. Elsey's
Published fragrance label: Unscented

Classic Litter

Published fragrance label: Unscented.

Key details

  • Base material: Clay.

What to note

Maker describes as clumping: Yes.

Base material: ClayMaker describes as clumping: YesPublished fragrance label: Unscented
See all 5 specs
Base materialClay
Maker describes as clumpingYes
Published fragrance labelUnscented
Recommended fill depth, minimum3 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum4 in

5 of 5 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
Dr. Elsey's · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at Dr. Elsey's
Also compare 5

Clean Tracks® Litter

Published fragrance label: Unscented.

Key details

  • Base material: Clay.

What to note

Maker describes as clumping: Yes.

Base material: ClayMaker describes as clumping: YesPublished fragrance label: Unscented
See all 5 specs
Base materialClay
Maker describes as clumpingYes
Published fragrance labelUnscented
Recommended fill depth, minimum3 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum4 in

5 of 5 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
Dr. Elsey's · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at Dr. Elsey's

Comparing Cat Attract® Litter · Fresh Linen Cat Litter

Compare

Save this comparison

Compare

The facts that differ

Choose up to three models to compare side by side.

2 identical specs shown. Details that do not apply to these models are omitted.

Published specification comparison
SpecCat Attract® LitterNo preferences selected.Fresh Linen Cat LitterNo preferences selected.
Base materialClayWheat
Maker describes as clumpingYesYes
Published fragrance labelNot listed by the makerAdded natural fragrance
Recommended fill depth, minimum3 in4 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum4 in4 in

Cat Attract® Litter

No preferences selected.

Base material
Clay
Maker describes as clumping
Yes
Published fragrance label
Not listed by the maker
Recommended fill depth, minimum
3 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum
4 in

Fresh Linen Cat Litter

No preferences selected.

Base material
Wheat
Maker describes as clumping
Yes
Published fragrance label
Added natural fragrance
Recommended fill depth, minimum
4 in
Recommended fill depth, maximum
4 in

Cat Attract® Litter

View at Dr. Elsey's

Fresh Linen Cat Litter

View at sWheat Scoop

Compare all 10 models

— = no verified listing yet. The published order is independent of links.

All models and their decision specs
ProductHow it comparesKey specCompareAction
Cat Attract® Litter
Compared with Fresh Linen Cat Litter: base material, Clay vs Wheat.
Base material: ClayView at Dr. Elsey's
Classic Litter
Compared with Ultra+ Litter: published fragrance label, Unscented vs No added perfume.
Base material: ClayView at Dr. Elsey's
Clean Tracks® Litter
Compared with Ultra+ Litter: published fragrance label, Unscented vs No added perfume.
Base material: ClayView at Dr. Elsey's
Paw Sensitive™ Litter
Compared with Triple Action Cat Litter: base material, Clay vs Wheat.
Base material: ClayView at Dr. Elsey's
Ultra Litter
Compared with Ultra+ Litter: published fragrance label, Unscented vs No added perfume.
Base material: ClayView at Dr. Elsey's
Ultra+ Litter
Published fragrance label: No added perfume; Base material: Clay.
Base material: ClayView at Dr. Elsey's
Fresh Linen Cat Litter
Compared with Paw Sensitive™ Litter: base material, Wheat vs Clay.
Base material: WheatView at sWheat Scoop
Cat Attract® Litter
Compared with Fresh Linen Cat Litter: base material, Clay vs Wheat.
Base material: Clay
View at Dr. Elsey's
Classic Litter
Compared with Ultra+ Litter: published fragrance label, Unscented vs No added perfume.
Base material: Clay
View at Dr. Elsey's
Clean Tracks® Litter
Compared with Ultra+ Litter: published fragrance label, Unscented vs No added perfume.
Base material: Clay
View at Dr. Elsey's
Paw Sensitive™ Litter
Compared with Triple Action Cat Litter: base material, Clay vs Wheat.
Base material: Clay
View at Dr. Elsey's
Ultra Litter
Compared with Ultra+ Litter: published fragrance label, Unscented vs No added perfume.
Base material: Clay
View at Dr. Elsey's
Ultra+ Litter
Published fragrance label: No added perfume; Base material: Clay.
Base material: Clay
View at Dr. Elsey's
Fresh Linen Cat Litter
Compared with Paw Sensitive™ Litter: base material, Wheat vs Clay.
Base material: Wheat
View at sWheat Scoop
10 catalog models

How the comparison works

Your choices are compared with each model’s product details. A missing or conflicting value stays unknown and cannot satisfy a choice you select. The starting order helps you browse; it does not rate real-world performance.

Source dates appear with each link below. A source date does not confirm today's price or stock.

Finder methodologyReport a correction
Sources for all 10 models

Material, scent wording and fill depth answer different questions

Dr. Elsey’s Classic uses clay with an unscented label; sWheat Scoop Original uses wheat with a no-added-perfume label. sWheat Scoop Fresh Linen carries an added-natural-fragrance label. Keep those maker phrases separate instead of treating every fragrance description as equivalent.

Dr. Elsey’s starting fill instructions span 3 to 4 in for these litters; sWheat Scoop’s start at 4 in. The minimum starting depths therefore range from 3 to 4 in. Follow the complete directions for the litter you choose rather than applying a depth rule from another material.

All 10 products have a material description and a clumping designation, but those fields do not measure odor control, dust or tracking.

Before you buy

Does no added perfume mean no smell?

Not quite. It means nothing scented was added, and wheat or clay might still carry a natural smell, which is why unscented and no added perfume stay separate labels here.

Why do two Dr. Elsey’s litters show no fragrance?

The Cat Attract and Paw Sensitive pages don’t give a fragrance line, so those two are blank and drop out if you pick a fragrance label.

Can I compare cost per pound?

Not here. None of these ten pages states a bag weight, so there’s nothing to divide a price by.

Is this every kind of litter?

Only clay and wheat clumping litters from two makers. Pine, corn, walnut, paper and silica litters aren’t covered, and neither are other brands, so follow the full directions on whichever bag you buy.